My car just coming to the end of the 3 month warranty, and they are offering to extend for 12 months at £230. Deal is they pay half of any eligible claim, less a £75 excess. My car is 2005 and done 34,000 miles, and I do less than 5,000 miles a year.
My assessment is that it would be useful if something really major went, but for anything around £400-£500 ish, I'd be better putting the £300 insurance cost (policy plus excess) towards the cost of the repair, if required. The difficulty is, of course, not being able to foresee what is going to happen. I don't drive the car hard, just the odd blast.
Any thoughts welcome, please