Hi, All mk5 golf wings are the same, just don't buy non genuine ones! Much better to buy some good used genuine ones, or bite the bullet and get new ones from tps, yes they are more expensive but they will fit perfectly, I work in an accident repair centre where non genuine panels are always used, and the quality and fit are shocking, leaving terrible panel gaps and mismatched swage lines. If things are cheap there's usually a reason....then again, maybe i'm just too fussy!