I doubt it, it took me hours to find out everything I needed to ensure I bought the correct second hand rack as I didn't want to go through the hassle of changing it more than once, and the true part number is hidden under a heatshield so you won't be finding it without removing the rack from the car...
Useful image showing the Gen 2 and 3. Gen 1 is usually only the oldest of the Mk5 platform but its worth checking before ordering a replacement