I bought 2 silver ones from Lothian car parts a month ago- fit is decent and colour is decent. If you know they have been changed, yeah you may spot the odd issue but for 170 there worth a go.
As there new paint and the rest of the car is 15 years old theres bound to be a difference, but you have to be really looking to tell.
I cur the bottom of the old foam off and undersealed the insides so hopefully wont be same issue in a year or two.