I think you will be happy with the one in "09Pirelli."
I use Pirelli PZ4...I've seen a number of test results where it outperforms (overall) tires like Michelin PS4S and Hankook Ventus S1 EVO3.
Here the PZ4 cost $178usd/ea for a 225/40-18. When, in the same size: Hankook Ventus S1 EVO3 is $249, and Michelin PS4S is $222.
Not saying, myself, they are better...as I haven't tested them all. Just saying what I found in looking at test results, and to say I am happy with them. They also do well on wet surfaces, and I live in the wet zone in the Pacific NW (NW Oregon).