8p s3 hubs do fit on to the mk5 yes. Well the gti hub is solid thick cast iron it's going to take 50 years for them to actually start to rust through, alloy doesn't rust but it still corrodes. But anyway they're a bit lighte being alloy so less unsprung weight, aside from that they're the same. The TT hubs give a higher roll centre and extend the track width but they don't bolt on so simply like the other VAG choices, they need the TT control arms at a minimum, some say they require the TT driveshaffs and steering arms but I've also known people to just bolt them straight on so yeah not as simple to do.