That's a tough one... But doing those miles I'd buy a daily with the 2.5k, buy cheaper one... Normally 1 owner is better than 3 owners, but it would have had 3 enthusiastic injections from each new owner...(hopefully!) as long as full vwsh then hopefully both been well looked over... Look at miles between services... Matching tyres... Door dents... Fag burns... These kinda stuff gives away if been looked after... But think how long you gonna keep too, car will be harder to sell with 100+k miles... And see which seller will move most on price... ;-)
View both cars first, condition matters more than mileage and owners IMO.If I was u tho, I'd be looking for one with a high spec such as Nav, Xenons, highline display & ideally DSG. For a car like that I'd pay a bit more. Candy white would be cool for an ED30
Could buy my 2007 2 owner (inc me), red, 3door, manual, sunrrof, FVVSH (major service inc cambelt+ pump just done) ED30 for £10k