depends on the offset but personally i think 8.5 is too wide on the mk5
8.5 works perfectly well on a Mk5. data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/20253/20253e388f4a3e8123dd96a98de7ee817b076a4c" alt="happy2 :happy2:"
Ideal width IMO.
It certainly does!! So much so I can't find ANY 8.5J RS style wheels anywhere!! Really not happy, as might have to settle with 8J and push the offset down to get some poke :(