I don't mind who is picked.
However.
This is going to be a calender that is on display at your house, work/office, garage, whatever. People will look at it and make their judgements/assumptions. It represents the forum, the members, and in a way, VW Golf drivers and enthusiasts.
The quality/composure of some of the shots chosen is not of a quality I would personally consider right for a calender. I'm not saying anything negative about the CARS chosen (as not a single car picked I would deem "un-caldenerable" - just the photos of said cars.
That's my opinion.
However I'll still buy one. And RR and the other guy have done a lot of work putting it all together. No-one has the same taste in cars, pictures, etc, and there's always going to be people who are unhappy.
So let's all cut people a break on what's picked and why.