You get what you pay for ....
We paid: £10,900 for a super clean 42k ED30 6 months ago, same dealer is still getting the same money for them today as they are good sellers. He gets more money for 07 plate s3 & R32's , they all sell very well.
When i was looking there were very few under 10k for sale. Now there are a some at around 9k
There is an 09 plate Ed30 on PH for £4300. This week
So over priced NO, in demand YES