But you are comparing a heavily modified mk5 to a standard mk7. Of course one is going to appear a bit "luke warm"
....Nowadays as my Mk5 is somewhat modified, yes. But I think it's still true regarding a stock OEM Mk5 compared with a Mk7. Just my opinion.
Coincidentally I saw a Mk7 drive past today and I want to like it but find I can't. I don't especially dislike the Mk7 and I prefer it to the Mk6 (except the Golf R) but it doesn't initiate any excitement whatsoever and that's sad that such an iconic brand as a GTI doesn't do so.
To be fair I haven't driven any Mk7 nor have I ridden in one. I reckon I would absolutely hate all those driving aid prompts etc. I could easily get a test drive but I simply don't feel inspired enough to arrange one. ETTO.