Take it the car in question is mine.
I've done all the normal checks, the car has a new PCV, DV and follower, plugs were checked and mint. Also did some logs on VCDS and it proved to be fine, I'll happily send them to you or even post them up on here.
Rick @ Unicorn had a look at the map, he said it isn't the worst, it could be improved to eek some more power out of it but the main thing is it's safe.
Don't think you can get more honest than that?