MK5 Golf GTI

General => Detailing => Topic started by: pudding on July 11, 2017, 03:55:38 pm

Title: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 11, 2017, 03:55:38 pm
So, long story short.....weekend just gone was my first venture into 'detailing' land, but I need to give the roof and bonnet a good seeing to.

I acquired a polishing machine some years ago but I'm too afraid to use it, with all the horror stories of melting bumpers and taking paint off etc, but I do have a tub of G3 polish.  Is that OK to use by hand? Or is there something better out there for a lovely smooth hand job?


Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: Rossimac on July 11, 2017, 04:15:48 pm
(https://imgur.com/Hx51HXn.jpg)
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: Paradox1 on July 11, 2017, 04:23:32 pm
(https://imgur.com/Hx51HXn.jpg)


 :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin:
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: RetroRaz on July 11, 2017, 04:24:11 pm
pun intended?
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 11, 2017, 05:23:03 pm
Of course it was  :smiley:

OK, to reword it to a more sensible forum friendly format - what is a good polish to use with a cloth, by hand?  I need to buff out some water marks from the roof and bonnet.  The rest of the car is fine, so not worth the effort and expense of a machine polish.

Is that better?  :grin:
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: Andy on July 11, 2017, 06:03:22 pm
ooh err  misses :grin:
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: AJP on July 11, 2017, 07:01:18 pm
You can't go wrong with Autoglym SRP. It's mildly abrasive so will deal with the water marks nicely, and also contains fillers, so it's good for swirls and small scratches.

Just don't over apply it, try and do it out of direct sunlight too. Microfibres help to stop it getting 'chalky'. Finish it off with a decent wax/sealant if you can be arsed. :)
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: willni on July 11, 2017, 10:35:55 pm
What polisher do you have? it's pretty much impossible to burn through the paint with a Dual Action.  Rotaries are the ones that will burn through the paint but mainly on edges.

To be honest for the amount of effort it is polishing by hand the reward in very very low. What i'd recommend is the following;

A all in one polish (it's more designed for hand loving  :grin:)
Then a coat of poorboy's blackhole  :wink: (these innuendos are getting out of hand now)
Then your choice of wax x 2 coats and the next step or 3 coats and finish.
To finish I recommend some Waxaddict's Fo'show spray wax and then reapply every 2-3 weeks

Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 12, 2017, 09:52:02 am
Cheers guys, gotta love some innuendos to brighten up a cloudy summers day  :grin:

I've got a rotary polisher which I borrowed off a mate about 10 years ago, but conveniently forgot to return.  I can't remember the make but he got good results with it on his car.  My car has some iffy paint in areas from previous owner cover ups, so I don't want to risk rubbing that off with the machine!

OK so bash some Super Resin on by hand, wipe it off, bung some blackhole on, wipe that off and then wax.  Cool, I think I can cope with that  :smiley: 

2-3 coats of wax  :surprised:   I normally put 1 coat on, but I could give 2 or 3 coats a bash.  I normally use Collinite 476 because I'm lazy and only give the car a thorough scrub once a year, but I missed last year's scrub up.......so it was more work this time around  :grin:

Oh, is there a chemical you can recommend to stop the rubber strips in the window runners and the sunroof seal from going green with moss/algae?

Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: willni on July 12, 2017, 11:38:54 am
Cheers guys, gotta love some innuendos to brighten up a cloudy summers day  :grin:

I've got a rotary polisher which I borrowed off a mate about 10 years ago, but conveniently forgot to return.  I can't remember the make but he got good results with it on his car.  My car has some iffy paint in areas from previous owner cover ups, so I don't want to risk rubbing that off with the machine!

OK so bash some Super Resin on by hand, wipe it off, bung some blackhole on, wipe that off and then wax.  Cool, I think I can cope with that  :smiley: 

2-3 coats of wax  :surprised:   I normally put 1 coat on, but I could give 2 or 3 coats a bash.  I normally use Collinite 476 because I'm lazy and only give the car a thorough scrub once a year, but I missed last year's scrub up.......so it was more work this time around  :grin:

Oh, is there a chemical you can recommend to stop the rubber strips in the window runners and the sunroof seal from going green with moss/algae?

Personally for hand polishing I'd recommend Kleenfreaks all in one, you'll save your arm/elbow and shoulder since it's a half polish so works easier.

2-3 coats of wax offers maximum protection and longevity  :happy2: , and yeah rotary actually puts more swirls in it for finishing so I wouldn't worry about using it.

For green moss and Algae some all purpose cleaner with a stiff brush (I use an old tooth brush for around sunroofs) do this for 3-5 washes and it will die permanently as well as point the powerhose down into the window and across to help blow out all dirt from the window.
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 12, 2017, 12:01:39 pm
Thanks mate, I'll get an order in.  Not cheap keeping these cars looking fresh!  Black does come up super lovely when it's shiny and clean though.
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: white91 on July 12, 2017, 12:07:25 pm
I did mine with a DAS6 Pro, first time machine polishing and it worked really well, you will never get a good finish by hand. I'd recommend checking out the detailing world forum to start with


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: Scottymon on July 12, 2017, 08:45:36 pm
HAHAHHAHAHA! What a great thread title! :D
But to concur, the DAS Pro is an awesome machine and far better than rotary for lack of "burn!" in amateur hands...

A good hand job to finish can never be overlooked however ;)
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: MIJ_JAGGER on July 12, 2017, 08:51:10 pm
Try using both hands, I'm sure it'll be a happy ending
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 13, 2017, 12:10:39 pm
Oooh now you're talking.  Will I benefit from some lube?

I'm hearing you guys on the FM about the Das 6 Pro.  Maybe I'll order one when I get paid.  Just looked online and they're not as pricey as I thought.  Is the starter pack cleanyourcar.com any good?  Comes with the machine, some pads and some polishes.  I really wouldn't know a good product from a bad one tbh.  There's a billion different detailing products to choose from!
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: willni on July 13, 2017, 12:36:12 pm
Oooh now you're talking.  Will I benefit from some lube?

I'm hearing you guys on the FM about the Das 6 Pro.  Maybe I'll order one when I get paid.  Just looked online and they're not as pricey as I thought.  Is the starter pack cleanyourcar.com any good?  Comes with the machine, some pads and some polishes.  I really wouldn't know a good product from a bad one tbh.  There's a billion different detailing products to choose from!

For a starter machine either of these two;

http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/polishing-machines/das-6-v2-dual-action-polisher/das-6-v2-meguiars-hexlogic-kit/prod_1805.html (http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/polishing-machines/das-6-v2-dual-action-polisher/das-6-v2-meguiars-hexlogic-kit/prod_1805.html)

http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/das-6-v2-meguiars-da-microfiber-system/prod_965.html (http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/das-6-v2-meguiars-da-microfiber-system/prod_965.html)

The more expensive one has a stronger cutting compound for deeper correction of swirls and scratches, and the pads will give you a better finish but you'll need to keep "re-fluffing" the pads during use to achieve the best finish.

The cheaper is a lot less abrasive but will only really fix medium swirls and scratches.

Although my recommendation of what I know works with the golf paint is the following kit, it's cheaper and gets the best finish in my opinion;

http://www.slimsdetailing.co.uk/accessories-kits-and-tools/polishing-machines/slims-detailing-dual-action-das-6-machine-polisher-koch-chemie-polish-kit.html (http://www.slimsdetailing.co.uk/accessories-kits-and-tools/polishing-machines/slims-detailing-dual-action-das-6-machine-polisher-koch-chemie-polish-kit.html)
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 17, 2017, 02:37:51 pm
Oooh now you're talking.  Will I benefit from some lube?

I'm hearing you guys on the FM about the Das 6 Pro.  Maybe I'll order one when I get paid.  Just looked online and they're not as pricey as I thought.  Is the starter pack cleanyourcar.com any good?  Comes with the machine, some pads and some polishes.  I really wouldn't know a good product from a bad one tbh.  There's a billion different detailing products to choose from!

For a starter machine either of these two;

http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/polishing-machines/das-6-v2-dual-action-polisher/das-6-v2-meguiars-hexlogic-kit/prod_1805.html (http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/polishing-machines/das-6-v2-dual-action-polisher/das-6-v2-meguiars-hexlogic-kit/prod_1805.html)

http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/das-6-v2-meguiars-da-microfiber-system/prod_965.html (http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/das-6-v2-meguiars-da-microfiber-system/prod_965.html)

The more expensive one has a stronger cutting compound for deeper correction of swirls and scratches, and the pads will give you a better finish but you'll need to keep "re-fluffing" the pads during use to achieve the best finish.

The cheaper is a lot less abrasive but will only really fix medium swirls and scratches.

Although my recommendation of what I know works with the golf paint is the following kit, it's cheaper and gets the best finish in my opinion;

http://www.slimsdetailing.co.uk/accessories-kits-and-tools/polishing-machines/slims-detailing-dual-action-das-6-machine-polisher-koch-chemie-polish-kit.html (http://www.slimsdetailing.co.uk/accessories-kits-and-tools/polishing-machines/slims-detailing-dual-action-das-6-machine-polisher-koch-chemie-polish-kit.html)

Thanks for the advice mate, very helpful  :smiley:   I'll get the Slims kit on pay day I think.
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: willni on July 17, 2017, 04:20:07 pm
Oooh now you're talking.  Will I benefit from some lube?

I'm hearing you guys on the FM about the Das 6 Pro.  Maybe I'll order one when I get paid.  Just looked online and they're not as pricey as I thought.  Is the starter pack cleanyourcar.com any good?  Comes with the machine, some pads and some polishes.  I really wouldn't know a good product from a bad one tbh.  There's a billion different detailing products to choose from!

For a starter machine either of these two;

http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/polishing-machines/das-6-v2-dual-action-polisher/das-6-v2-meguiars-hexlogic-kit/prod_1805.html (http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/polishing-machines/das-6-v2-dual-action-polisher/das-6-v2-meguiars-hexlogic-kit/prod_1805.html)

http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/das-6-v2-meguiars-da-microfiber-system/prod_965.html (http://www.cleanyourcar.co.uk/das-6-v2-meguiars-da-microfiber-system/prod_965.html)

The more expensive one has a stronger cutting compound for deeper correction of swirls and scratches, and the pads will give you a better finish but you'll need to keep "re-fluffing" the pads during use to achieve the best finish.

The cheaper is a lot less abrasive but will only really fix medium swirls and scratches.

Although my recommendation of what I know works with the golf paint is the following kit, it's cheaper and gets the best finish in my opinion;

http://www.slimsdetailing.co.uk/accessories-kits-and-tools/polishing-machines/slims-detailing-dual-action-das-6-machine-polisher-koch-chemie-polish-kit.html (http://www.slimsdetailing.co.uk/accessories-kits-and-tools/polishing-machines/slims-detailing-dual-action-das-6-machine-polisher-koch-chemie-polish-kit.html)

Thanks for the advice mate, very helpful  :smiley:   I'll get the Slims kit on pay day I think.

No problem I'll get a picture later on of what red turns out like with that koch chemie and poorboys black hole, but put it like this even when dirty you'll be able to see yourself in it  :happy2: probably should've done this earlier so you can put products to a picture.
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: willni on July 17, 2017, 06:52:12 pm
As promised pictures of the same three polishes followed by poorboys blackhole, then coated in one of waxaddict's waxes

(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20170717/e3bf875195fcfe6d729fedaa8e031991.png)

(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20170717/961b2b5cdcf3d7e17f7ef413f3186727.jpg)

(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20170717/58f18c87e8851cd0ae9afd2f2845642a.jpg)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: grey golfster on July 18, 2017, 09:40:13 am
To get back on the innuendo track...

I've always found the ladies of Gdynia to be particular good.....



ooooh errr etc!  :signLOL:
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 18, 2017, 01:02:55 pm
 :grin:

Looking great Willni  :happy2:  I need to learn how to be patient with this kind of work as the results are amazing. I'm guessing that takes all day?

Slightly off topic but I stumbled onto a YouTube clip about CarPro Cquartz last night. Some kind of ceramic coating.  How does that compare to waxing? It seems to suit the once-twice a year guys like me  :smiley:
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: willni on July 18, 2017, 01:57:46 pm
:grin:

Looking great Willni  :happy2:  I need to learn how to be patient with this kind of work as the results are amazing. I'm guessing that takes all day?

Slightly off topic but I stumbled onto a YouTube clip about CarPro Cquartz last night. Some kind of ceramic coating.  How does that compare to waxing? It seems to suit the once-twice a year guys like me  :smiley:

Well I actually spent a week on it, mainly because I only did 2 panels at a time as there was no rush so really a good job can be done in a day, but it's easier to do it in 2 days.

And I know of CarPro CQuartz, I opted for Gtechniq Crystal Serum Light and Exo V2 on mine a different brand of ceramic coat it lasts 5 years and needs topped up every 2 years. Personally I use ceramic coat on all mine as well as I put it on other peoples on weekends with gtechniq the Crystal Serum Light (CSL) doesn't scratch so it freezes the paint so you won't scratch it etc and resists uv damage and people hitting it. The top coat of exo v2/v3 does scratch but it can be removed and reapplied easily.

I think it's brilliant and leaves the car looking show condition all year round, and you don't have to worry about the paint. The trade off it application and preparation, it does require a lot of energy to ensure all the CSL is buffed off so not to leave any unsightly marks as well as the paint needs to people how you want it since 5 years is a long time so you want it to be perfect. You can pay people for it but professionals cost £600+ I think maybe more, I apply it for £300 dependant on condition in both cases.

If you apply it yourself you just need to take your time though. Summary definitely worth it as it self cleans, prevents scratching and some stone chipping and looks epic. Down side cost or effort to apply.

I'll try and find a dark colour I applied it to so you can get an idea but if you have metallic paint be prepared to smile at your car every time you see it in the sun.  :happy2:

Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: willni on July 18, 2017, 02:05:48 pm
Awful photos but you get the point on reflectivity of the paint with ceramic on it

Here we got found a deep metallic navy blue, used to look black.

(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20170718/789607ec4eed0482e750b797977218c9.png)

Along with a mineral metallic grey.

(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20170718/03c2e812863ec6a6134d0eae0e7111b1.png)

Sorry no other photos from after I completed them.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 19, 2017, 09:27:55 am
Thanks for the very detailed reply!  I like the sound of this ceramic stuff!   Is it good for wheels too?

Where are you based?  I'm thinking it might be better to get a pro to do it, but you would probably baulk at the state of my paint  :grin:

It's not that bad really, just needs some attention.....and the front end repainting to be perfect, but stone chips don't offend me that much as they are inevitable unfortunately.
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: willni on July 19, 2017, 09:44:15 am
Thanks for the very detailed reply!  I like the sound of this ceramic stuff!   Is it good for wheels too?

Where are you based?  I'm thinking it might be better to get a pro to do it, but you would probably baulk at the state of my paint  :grin:

It's not that bad really, just needs some attention.....and the front end repainting to be perfect, but stone chips don't offend me that much as they are inevitable unfortunately.

Yep it does it all Paint, Wheels, Brake Calipers, exhausts, plastic trim and glass, my wheels have been coated with C5 and EXO v2 and they have no brake dust or tar on then at all from a year of driving just washed weekly or so. I'm in Northern Ireland so be cheaper to go to someone local after time and travel  :sad1: . Also stonechips aren't hard to repair if you have a DA polisher it's just a matter of cleaning it and applying the touch up and then sanding it down to level, and polishing out the sanding marks.  :happy2:

And it's the inside of cars that are the worst the state that some people sit in, there's a reason I have thick plastic gloves  :signLOL: :sick:
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: lukemk5gti on July 19, 2017, 10:22:17 am
Didn't read the thread but I thought I would weigh in if not mentioned.

I've used CarPro Essence both by hand and machine and it's amazing.

It's kind of a one4all being a mild abrasive polish and it contains silicone dioxide which protects the paint.
Title: Re: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: pudding on July 19, 2017, 04:07:51 pm
Cheers guys, more food for thought.   Yeah Ireland is probably not doable Willni  :grin:
Title: Best Polish for a hand job
Post by: richardmlldk on August 09, 2017, 07:46:11 am
It is OK to use most of our products designed for paint on headlights or taillights but like others have said it all depends on what your goal is.  We recommend using the least aggressive approach as always.  Ultimate Polish can be used by Hand or Dual Action Polisher to remove light swirls & enhance clarity on headlights or taillights.  It would be recommended to follow up with a coat of wax or some type of protectant after use to provide protection to the factory coating on the headlights.