MK5 Golf GTI
All Things Mk5 => Mk5 General Area => Topic started by: GE90 on February 20, 2010, 08:01:16 pm
-
Hi all
After a short time in a new 2009 Impreza STi, I have decided that I cannot live with the very harsh ride, poor interior and the unwanted attention that it recieves. Due to a change of jobs, I also use it around town mostly, which does not really suit it.
I have been offered a fair price as a straight purchase at the local Subaru dealer, and have been on the look out for a GTi. I have found a Dec 2008 Edition 30, with the right spec. I am told taht it is fully loaded with options, inc sunroof, sat nav, cd changer, winter pack, smokers pack, luxury pack, xenons, cruise, heated seats, parking sensors, 2 yr service pack etc. Does anyone know what these packs consist of? Also, what do people think about the sat nav system?
My main concern is the ride, is it considered very harsh around town. Also, it the edition 30 laggy or difficult to drive in town?
I need to decide tomorrow, so any feebdack or thoughts on the above would be very welcome.
Thanks very much
-
Welcome to the forum. :happy2:
You are only going to get positive answer's on here, why cant you take it for a test drive :chicken:
-
ooh me first up....not sure about the ed30 but my gti is a joy wherever i am i town twisties and esp short straight roads where i can burst and oveertake almost anything i wanna :evilgrin:
and if its fully loaded then yessireeeeeeeee!#
matsu
-
Service Pack includes 'free' servicing. Normally a pretty good deal.
Sat nav - depends on the model. MFD2 is wank, rns510 is ace, chances are you have the former.
I don't think the ride is harsh - I'd call it controlled. SWIMBO complains it makes her jiggle though...
I find the engine on mine laggy low-down, but once you have a fair amount of revs on lag isn't a problem. I personally think this is a good thing as it means if I short shift it is easy to drive slowly, and you get good fuel economy.
Go for it, you won't regret the change.
-
Thanks all - just the quick replies I was seeking!
The car is some 200 miles away, and I cannot find one locally to try..... the sat nav is described as DVD sat nav if that makes a difference? Is the suspension stiffened on the ED30? Is the Bluetooth quite compatable (Blackberry)?
Thanks again all!
-
I will straight swap you for a white 08 plate ed30 :grin:
Kev
-
Sat nav is cool, dont expect a comfy ride though IMO, there a bit choppy , GTi and ED30 share the same suspension
-
The turbo on the edition 30 is bigger than the one on the GTI and so kicks in later (2750 instead 1750 i think?) which is why there's a lag but TBH if I know I'm gonna need the power eg overtake I drop down a gear so I'm using maximum power.
Don't find the ride particularly harsh but never owned a scooby to compare it with.
-
Thanks all - I think I neeed to drive one tomorrow!
Looking at the photo I have, it looks like the RNS 510 unit (I compared with Goggle images).
Just slightly concerned that the ride and lag won't be much of a improvement over the Subaru. Am I right in saying that the ride should be no different to a std GTI with 18"s?
-
Thanks all - I think I neeed to drive one tomorrow!
Looking at the photo I have, it looks like the RNS 510 unit (I compared with Goggle images).
Just slightly concerned that the ride and lag won't be much of a improvement over the Subaru. Am I right in saying that the ride should be no different to a std GTI with 18"s?
The ride is fine its a sporty family hatch. :happy2:
And the lag on the KO 4 is hardly noticable. There are a few people on here come from Scooby's and they have never looked back.
The RNS 510 is renowned as one of the best touch screen nav units there is. it is only let down by the 4 digit postcode recognition. Still great though. :smiley:
-
Probably going to be shot down in flames but.
I think you will hate the lack of traction after the scooby.
The answer to some extent is the White line kit, but you won't get the grip of the 4wd system.
I also miss the flat 4 sound of the scooby, it still turns my head.
If it was my money I would be looking at an Audi S3.
Sorry if I have offended anyone just my 2p
-
I had an S3 which I sold to get a deposit for a house. I then got a promotion so had more money and bought an Impreza turbo. I kept it for 2 months then got totally sick of it's crap interior and harsh ride. I part ex'd it for MY S3, which the dealer still had in! :grin:
I reckon the S3 is much better than an Impreza for an ervery day car and the GTI also beats it too (although the traction is poo in comparison).
-
well i prefer the gti ovber the impreza... dont get me wrong the impreza is unreal for puttin the power down but i really like the smooth power from my gti.... thats just my opinion... i cam from a 03 300bhp wrx to a standard gti and im well pleased.. and im sure you will too. the power is so smooth and without the boyracer noise
-
Hi all
After a short time in a new 2009 Impreza STi, I have decided that I cannot live with the very harsh ride, poor interior and the unwanted attention that it recieves. Due to a change of jobs, I also use it around town mostly, which does not really suit it.
I have been offered a fair price as a straight purchase at the local Subaru dealer, and have been on the look out for a GTi. I have found a Dec 2008 Edition 30, with the right spec. I am told taht it is fully loaded with options, inc sunroof, sat nav, cd changer, winter pack, smokers pack, luxury pack, xenons, cruise, heated seats, parking sensors, 2 yr service pack etc. Does anyone know what these packs consist of? Also, what do people think about the sat nav system?
My main concern is the ride, is it considered very harsh around town. Also, it the edition 30 laggy or difficult to drive in town?
I need to decide tomorrow, so any feebdack or thoughts on the above would be very welcome.
Thanks very much
........sounds like a good one mate.I would go for it. I love my standard GTI & if i had had a bit more cash i would def of had an edition 30.
-
Hi GE90, welcome to the forum,
below is the put of my standard ED30 from the Briskoda RR day yesterday, as you can see they make 160 ish ft/lb at 2000 rpm which i find makes the car easy to drive around town.
There are a suite of great cars in the VAG product range, so you can pay's your money and take your choice. :happy2:
You won't regret it :drinking:
(https://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fdaz.co%2Fmedia%2Fad39%2Fnorthernthor%2FEditon30Standardplot.jpg&hash=6a7bcf2385d2f11fa0c498469dccbaf45db447e1)
-
Thanks for the welcomes and replies!
Right, I have just returned from driving an ED30! It had DSG, which was great, but I sure I will be happy with the manual. Loved everything about it, although cannot comment on performance really, as I did not explore the DSG much.
However..... just a niggling doubt about the ride, seems too similar to my Impreza - a little choppy. Although it is difficult to be sure on a short test drive on unfamiliar roads. It might just be that it is firm but not fugutty like the Impreza?
Need to do some more thinking!
-
I've come from 2 Scoobies (via a collection of BM's and other odds n sods) to an Edition 30.
IMHO the car is a good compromise.
Will it have the grip and absolute power of the scooby? Nope.
Is it more comfortable? Well, it's more comfortable than the scoobies I had.
Is it easy to drive through town? Mines a joy (DSG)
Does it have the running costs of the Scooby? Nope. Insurance much lower and if you drive in the same way I reckon you'll save a good chunk at the pumps too.
That said, the ride is still on the firm side. I think it's fine you have to remember that this is a sporting car on a similar size platform to the Scooby so it is still solid but it's more than acceptable. I do a 100-mile M25 commute and find it fine. However, this is a personal thing. If you want a magic carpet ride go buy an S-Class Merc :wink:
It doesn't attract the wrong attention either.
I'm one of those that wouldn't go back. I loved my Impreza's. I still love the sound of them and the way they drive but, in my opinion they've had their day in the sun. When I bought my first one they had a waiting list of over a year and were changing hands for more money second hand than new coss you just couldnt' get them. This kept the image strong and the cars were fantastic. There was nothing that gave anything like the bangs per buck in terms of performance. However things change. When I had the first one and people asked what I drove I'd get nods of approval and respect. Contrast that to their image today. That coupled with quicker hot hatches has shifted the balance in my opinion.
Or am I just getting old? :wink:
-
That said, the ride is still on the firm side. I think it's fine you have to remember that this is a sporting car on a similar size platform to the Scooby so it is still solid but it's more than acceptable. I do a 100-mile M25 commute and find it fine. However, this is a personal thing. If you want a magic carpet ride go buy an S-Class Merc :wink:
It doesn't attract the wrong attention either.
I'm one of those that wouldn't go back. I loved my Impreza's. I still love the sound of them and the way they drive but, in my opinion they've had their day in the sun. When I bought my first one they had a waiting list of over a year and were changing hands for more money second hand than new coss you just couldnt' get them. This kept the image strong and the cars were fantastic. There was nothing that gave anything like the bangs per buck in terms of performance. However things change. When I had the first one and people asked what I drove I'd get nods of approval and respect. Contrast that to their image today. That coupled with quicker hot hatches has shifted the balance in my opinion.
Or am I just getting old? :wink:
Couldn't have written it better. I did love my Scooby when I first got it and the one after that. But now I think they are for Chavs and a younger generation. Except the new one looks more like a Ford Focus (to me) and appeals once again.
Yep I am getting and feeling old too :signLOL:
Depending on what you have to spend, a used M3 would be quite high on my list. And deffo the S3. I just don't like the Audi 3 series interior espcially the dash with the "two tittie" air vents. Just my taste.
From a 4WD the S3 would be my choice over the ED30 (but I only have a GTI with DSG). Round town I think the GTI is better than the ED30 - feels quicker and more responsive to me. (Ducking for cover) But I only had an ED30 for a couple of days.
What ever you get GTI, ED30 or S3 you will not be disappointed.
-
Again, thanks - I tend to agree with the replies regarding the Impreza. I too had a classic from new, and therefore remember the long waiting lists too!
Just a shame I couldn't find manual to test, as I could not feel how laggy it might be around town. I am assuming that it won't be as much as the Impreza.....
Really swaying towards the Golf now, especially after considering the £435 road tax that will be due soon, and the factory tracker yearly subs etc. The Golf will be cheaper on tax, and free servicing for two years.
I assume that my Blackberry would work with the Bluetooth - searched for a compatalibity list with no success.
I did consider the A3, but it would be older for my budget and I really need a 5 door as I have a newborn!
-
Right, thats it - accepted offer on the Subaru today, going to view and hopefully pick up the ED30 on Friday!
Thanks again to all, and I will update this thread after Friday.
-
Right, thats it - accepted offer on the Subaru today, going to view and hopefully pick up the ED30 on Friday!
Thanks again to all, and I will update this thread after Friday.
No need to update this thread. once you have your car, we need loads of pics in your members ride thread. :jumpmove:
-
Hi all
Well, just returned from a mammoth trip to Devon, and I am now the proud owner of a Dec 2008 ED30! Really very impressed so far, and exactly what I was looking for in every way! I will post a review shortly. In the meantime, just a few more questions I am affraid!
I have a very slight noise when taking up drive (like a rumble), but no vibration at all - any ideas?
Very slight noise when braking at speed, but again, no vibration...
Any tyre recommendations? Comfort is high on my list - Michelin Pilot Sport 3's?
The user manual for the sat nav rns510 is missing - will try my local dealer, but would someone be willing to copy one for me - I'll pay for your time and postage.
What is the best way of getting the Edition 30 plaque?
Thanks for your help!
-
Sorry, just one more! Can OEM Bluetooth be retrofitted - I have the rns510
Thanks!
-
Nice one, Good to hear your enjoying the car, now get some pictures posted up in the members rides section.
With reagrds to the Q's
Bluetooth can be retro fitted with the RNS510, number of options are available. all are discussed in the modifications and techncail area of the forum.
The are lots of threads about the plaques for the Ed30 along with the other Q's you have? search function is your friend and there is lots of great advice on here, there is a huge number of very knowledgable individuals on this forum. :happy2:
Here's a link to a pdf of the manual for the RNS510 http://www.primeprestige.com/oemretrofits/manuals/RNS510-MFD3-Manual.pdf (http://www.primeprestige.com/oemretrofits/manuals/RNS510-MFD3-Manual.pdf) :happy2:
Once again welcome to the mad house :laugh: :laugh: now get some pics up :party:
-
Great, thanks - I'll give the search function a good working!
This might be a strange question, but must the sat nav DVD stay in while it is operating, or can the maps be copied over in some way?
Thanks again!
-
ooh me first up....not sure about the ed30 but my gti is a joy wherever i am i town twisties and esp short straight roads where i can burst and oveertake almost anything i wanna :evilgrin:
and if its fully loaded then yessireeeeeeeee!#
matsu
This is the point as Matsu describes, the GTI/Ed30's may not be the absolute best in certain situations, but as an all rounder it will never let you down. In my opinion it's still the best hot hatch to live with and will leave you smiling :smiley:
-
Great, thanks - I'll give the search function a good working!
This might be a strange question, but must the sat nav DVD stay in while it is operating, or can the maps be copied over in some way?
Thanks again!
You can upload new maps onto the HDD in the RNS510, just pop the disc in and it will do the rest. The latest maps are Version 6.
HTH
-
Just uploaded a few photos!
http://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,12756.msg190493.html#new (http://www.mk5golfgti.co.uk/forum/index.php/topic,12756.msg190493.html#new)