Ive got the S3/TTRS one fitted, bought direct for VW for about £20.
It is shorter than standard, but not a massive change, maybe 20% ish shorter. I like it, but probably not for everyone as the throw isnt as short as the forge anzd other aftermarket ones as far as I know.
Easy peasy to fit though and ignore all these youtube vids etc which say remove battery and tray...waste of time, can be done with it all in place.