I'm going to say it again....a FVWSH is meaningless tosh!
IMHO of course....
Only if the dealer is a crap one.
Well, yes, of course....... Probably...
But then not all the mechanics at a specific dealer will be good, or bad. Even the good ones have bad days etc etc etc...
I was really referring to the "gold standard" that some folks believe exists when see a FVWSH car.
I'm with the above comments re trusted specialists,
and as for paying £149/hr to a VW stealer in London!?!
I totally get it, and it frustrates me too that some people would turn down a great car, just because it doesn't have dealer stamps, or a wad of VW headed invoices.
It's unfortunately how Brits have been indoctrinated. I think a lot of people believe franchised dealers are VW themselves and their car will serviced by the people who assembled it!
Some of it comes down to circumstance. I'm lucky enough to have found a decent dealer that is a 5 min walk from work, and I get on with the parts people too. My trusted indie is 150 miles away, so I don't get many opportunities to go up there. Big jobs like suspension, clutches and mapping I always take to him.