I'm just playing Hedge (don't get your frilly knickers in a twist!)
My vote would be for the Vreds, got them on now and had them on my old golf. Great value for money, especially as they're on offer at the mo. I can only compare them to Dunlop TTs though. They seem to grip alot better in the wet, got nice n meaty tread, they look good too.
Heard a lot of good reviews for the Asymmetrics, but also heard a few problems with them too.
The toyos may be a little cheaper but I don't think they wear too well.